A housing society cannot automatically claim ownership of a member’s money simply by describing a payment as “non-refundable.” If a society wants to retain money collected from a member, it must be able to show that the collection and retention are supported by law, the society’s registered bye-laws or a valid agreement.
A Co-operative Court recently highlighted this principle while directing RNA Regency Park Tower Co-operative Housing Society in Kandivali West, Mumbai, to return ₹50,000 to members Jignesh Khiraiya and Kusum K Khiraiya.
The court ordered the society to pay the couple ₹50,000 along with 6% simple interest per year. The interest will run from January 30, 2022, when the society received their written request for repayment, until the amount is recovered. The society was also directed to bear the couple’s legal expenses.
The dispute over a parking payment
The dispute began in 2017 when the couple transferred their flat in the housing society.
During the transfer process, they paid ₹75,000 as a deposit for stilt parking. They also paid a separate ₹25,000 transfer premium demanded by the society.
According to the couple, the parking amount was based on a general body resolution passed by the society on June 10, 2012. The resolution required incoming members to pay ₹75,000 for stilt parking, in addition to the transfer premium.
The couple initially paid the amount as demanded. However, they later questioned the society’s decision to treat the parking payment as non-refundable.
Following their objection, the society returned or credited ₹25,000 to their maintenance account but continued to hold the remaining ₹50,000.
The couple then approached the Co-operative Court, arguing that the society had no lawful reason to retain the balance.
Society cited repair expenses
The society did not deny collecting the money. Instead, it attempted to justify retaining the ₹50,000 by referring to expenses incurred for major repairs.
It claimed that parking-related collections had been used toward repair work costing approximately ₹9 lakh.
However, the court found that the society had not provided adequate documentary evidence to support this claim.
This was important because simply showing that a society has incurred large expenses does not establish that it can use or retain a particular member’s payment for those expenses.
A society may have legitimate maintenance and repair costs, but it still needs proper authority to collect money from members and retain it for a particular purpose.
Court questioned the legal basis of the charge
The court examined the documents produced in the case, including payment receipts, the general body resolution and correspondence between the couple and the society.
After considering the material, the court found that the society had failed to demonstrate a valid legal basis for keeping ₹50,000.
The disputed payment was connected with the transfer of membership and parking. However, the society could not establish that the amount was supported by its registered bye-laws, a separate agreement with the members or a clearly established service provided in exchange for the payment.
This meant that the society could not rely solely on the description “non-refundable” to justify keeping the money.
The court’s reasoning is significant because the nature of a payment is determined by its legal foundation, not merely by the label placed on it.
General body approval does not override the law
One of the broader issues considered by the court was the society’s general body resolution.
Housing societies routinely use general body meetings to approve decisions concerning members, finances, maintenance and common facilities. However, a resolution passed by members cannot automatically create a legal power that the society does not otherwise possess.
The court referred to earlier judicial decisions which held that a general body resolution cannot authorise a society to collect amounts that are not permitted under the applicable law.
In other words, internal approval is not the same as legal authority.
Even if members have approved a particular charge, the society must still ensure that the charge complies with the relevant legal framework and its registered bye-laws.
Why the ₹50,000 had to be returned
The central issue was not simply whether the society had spent money on repairs. The key question was whether it had a lawful right to retain this particular amount paid by the couple.
The court concluded that the society had failed to establish that right.
The absence of supporting documents regarding the claimed repair expenditure further weakened the society’s position. It could not adequately demonstrate that the ₹50,000 was lawfully appropriated toward the alleged expenses.
The court therefore ordered the society to return the amount.
It also directed that the couple receive 6% simple interest annually, starting from January 30, 2022, when they formally demanded repayment.
Section 72 of the Indian Contract Act
The court also referred to Section 72 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, which deals with the obligation to repay money received under certain circumstances, including payments made by mistake or without a valid legal basis.
The provision supported the court’s conclusion that an unauthorised collection could not simply be retained.
The principle is straightforward: receiving money does not automatically mean that the recipient has the right to keep it.
Where a society cannot establish the legal basis for a collection, the amount may have to be returned.
What does the ruling mean for society members?
The case offers an important lesson for people living in co-operative housing societies.
Members may encounter different types of charges during flat transfers, parking arrangements, membership changes or other transactions. Sometimes these payments may be described as deposits, contributions, premiums or non-refundable charges.
The ruling suggests that members should not assume that a payment is legally valid merely because it appears in a society demand letter or has been approved through an internal resolution.
At the same time, the decision does not mean that every parking charge or society collection is illegal.
A society can impose legitimate charges when they are properly authorised under the applicable law, rules, registered bye-laws or valid contractual arrangements.
The important distinction is whether the society can demonstrate the legal authority behind the particular payment.
A wider message for housing societies
The dispute also highlights the importance of maintaining proper financial records.
When a society collects significant amounts from its members, it should be able to explain the purpose of the collection and maintain documents showing how the money is being used.
If a society claims that members’ payments were used for major repairs or other expenses, supporting bills, records and resolutions can become important evidence.
In this case, the lack of sufficient documentary proof made it difficult for the society to justify retaining the disputed amount.
The key takeaway
The Co-operative Court’s decision sends a clear message: calling a payment “non-refundable” does not automatically make it non-refundable in law.
A housing society must have a valid legal foundation for collecting and retaining a member’s money. A general body resolution alone cannot authorise a charge that is otherwise not permitted.
For Jignesh and Kusum Khiraiya, this meant the return of the ₹50,000 retained by their society, along with 6% annual interest and legal costs.
For other housing society members, the case serves as a reminder to ask an important question whenever an additional charge is demanded: What is the legal basis for this payment, and why is the society entitled to keep it?
If a society cannot provide a lawful and properly documented answer, its right to retain the money may be open to challenge.

Comments
Post a Comment